Who is for or against Jesus?
The sayings classify uncertain allegiance in opposite practical directions, though both eliminate a neutral category if applied to the same binary division.
- Textual conflict
- Weak contradiction
- The supplied passages do not establish incompatible claims. Different events, meanings, or conditions may account for the difference.
- Importance
- Major
- A major event or claim with wider implications.
Under the same binary categories the sayings are contrapositives, and the differing practical settings do not create a logical opposition.
An editorial assessment of the quoted passages. Importance describes the stakes; it does not increase certainty. Reading order weighs both.
Anyone not with Jesus counts as against him
He that is not with me is against me; and he that gathereth not with me scattereth abroad.
He that is not with me is against me: and he that gathereth not with me scattereth.
Anyone not against the disciples counts as for them
For he that is not against us is on our part.
And Jesus said unto him, Forbid him not: for he that is not against us is for us.
Understanding the contradiction
Matthew 12:30 and Luke 11:23 treat failure to join Jesus as opposition and failure to gather as scattering. Mark 9:40 and Luke 9:50 instead treat absence of opposition as support. The latter accompanies an instruction not to forbid someone, making its inclusive practical effect explicit.
These sound opposed because one starts from missing support and the other from missing hostility. Strictly, if 'for' and 'against' are the same two categories throughout, both statements deny neutrality and are logically compatible. The wording also shifts from 'me' to 'us.' The genuine tension is their different use as rules for dealing with outsiders: one makes affiliation decisive, while the other permits activity on the basis of nonopposition.