Which came first: the calling of Peter and Andrew or the imprisonment of John the Baptist?
Matthew and Mark place the fishermen's call after John's arrest, while John gives Andrew and Peter an earlier encounter with Jesus.
- Textual conflict
- Weak tension
- The alleged conflict needs substantial assumptions, such as treating an omission as a denial or figurative language as literal.
- Importance
- Major
- A major event or claim with wider implications.
Andrew's earlier introduction of Peter need not be the same event as the later lakeside summons after John's arrest.
An editorial assessment of the quoted passages. Importance describes the stakes; it does not increase certainty. Reading order weighs both.
The lakeside call follows John's imprisonment
Now when Jesus had heard that John was cast into prison, he departed into Galilee;
And Jesus, walking by the sea of Galilee, saw two brethren, Simon called Peter, and Andrew his brother, casting a net into the sea: for they were fishers. And he saith unto them, Follow me, and I will make you fishers of men.
Now after that John was put in prison, Jesus came into Galilee, preaching the gospel of the kingdom of God, And saying, The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand: repent ye, and believe the gospel. Now as he walked by the sea of Galilee, he saw Simon and Andrew his brother casting a net into the sea: for they were fishers. And Jesus said unto them, Come ye after me, and I will make you to become fishers of men.
Andrew brings Peter to Jesus before John's imprisonment
One of the two which heard John speak, and followed him, was Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother. He first findeth his own brother Simon, and saith unto him, We have found the Messias, which is, being interpreted, the Christ. And he brought him to Jesus. And when Jesus beheld him, he said, Thou art Simon the son of Jona: thou shalt be called Cephas, which is by interpretation, A stone.
After these things came Jesus and his disciples into the land of Judea; and there he tarried with them, and baptized. And John also was baptizing in Ænon near to Salim, because there was much water there: and they came, and were baptized. For John was not yet cast into prison.
Understanding the contradiction
Mark 1:14-17 expressly begins Jesus' Galilean preaching after John has been imprisoned and then describes the call of Simon and Andrew beside the sea. Matthew 4:12 similarly makes news of the imprisonment precede Jesus' move into Galilee, with the call appearing in Matthew 4:18-19. Both present the brothers as working fishermen whom Jesus summons to a new occupation of gathering people.
John 1:40-42 instead shows Andrew following Jesus after hearing John and then bringing Simon to him. John 3:22-24 later says that John had not yet been imprisoned, placing this earlier meeting before the arrest. These are different accounts of how the relationship begins, but an initial introduction and a subsequent summons are not explicitly identified as the same act in the excerpts. The firm discrepancy is in the narrated origin and timing of the brothers' association with Jesus. Calling it a direct chronological contradiction requires the further assumption that every described encounter is the single, exclusive beginning of discipleship.